416 Views
November 27, 18
スライド概要
2018/10/26
Deep Learning JP:
http://deeplearning.jp/seminar-2/
DL輪読会資料
ڧԽֶशͷͨΊͷঢ়ଶදֶݱश ɹʔΑΓྑ͍ʮੈքϞσϧʯͷ֫ಘʹ͚ͯʔ Tatsuya Matsushima @__tmats__ , Matsuo Lab 1
ྠಡ༰ʹ͍ͭͯ ຊൃදͰϕʔεͱ͍ͯ͠Δจ 4UBUF3FQSFTFOUBUJPO-FBSOJOHGPS$POUSPM"O0WFSWJFX • IUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT -BTUSFWJTFE+VO • 5JNPUIÉF-FTPSU /BUBMJB%ÍB[3PESÍHVF[ +FBO'SBOÇPJT(PVEPV %BWJE'JMMJBU • 43-5PPMCPYͱ͍͏πʔϧ࡞͍ͯ͠ΔIUUQTHJUIVCDPNBSBGGJOSPCPUJDTSMTSM • ੍ޚλεΫʹ༻͍Δঢ়ଶͷදֶݱशʹؔ͢ΔϨϏϡʔจ • 6$#FSLFMFZΛத৺ʹΜʹ͞ڀݚΕ͍ͯΔ • ຊͰ͋Μ·Γ͕͢ؾ͍ͳݟΔ • Χόʔ͞Ε͍ͯͳ͍ଞͷจຊൃදͰՃͨ͠ 2
ঢ়ଶදֶݱश(SRL)ͱʁ දֶݱश SFQSFTFOUBUJPOMFBSOJOH • σʔλ͔ΒBCTUSVDUͳಛΛ͚ͭݟΔֶश ঢ়ଶදֶݱश TUBUFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOMFBSOJOH 43- • ঢ়ଶ TUBUF දͱݱɼֶशͨ͠ಛ͕࣍Ͱݩɼ࣌ؒతʹൃల͠ɼΤʔδΣϯτͷߦಈͷ ӨڹΛड͚Δͷ • ͜ͷΑ͏ͳදݱϩϘςΟΫε੍ޚʹ༗ӹͰ͋Δͱߟ͑ΒΕΔDG ࣍ݩͷढ͍ • ྫ ը૾ใඇৗʹߴ͕࣍ͩݩɼϩϘοτͷ੍ޚͷతؔͬͱ࣍ʹݩද͞ݱΕ͏Δ • ϚχϐϡϨʔγϣϯͷ߹ɼମͷ࣍ݩͷҐஔใ • ੜͷ؍ଌσʔλ͔Β͜ͷঢ়ଶදݱΛ͚ͭݟΔख๏ͷ͕ڀݚओཁͳςʔϚ 3
ੈքϞσϧ ೳʹ͓͚Δ.PEFM#VJMEJOH<-BLF >ͷॏཁੑ • ਓؒ͋ΒΏΔͷΛ֮Ͱ͖ΔΘ͚Ͱ͘ɼใ ܹ ͔ΒੈքΛϞσϧԽͨ͠෦Ϟ σϧΛ࡞Γɼਓؒͷೳʹେ͖ͳׂΛ୲͍ͬͯΔͱࢥΘΕΔ • ੈքϞσϧͱ͍͏ • <%-ྠಡձ>(2/ͱؔ࿈ڀݚɼੈքϞσϧͱͷؔʹ͍ͭͯ IUUQTXXXTMJEFTIBSFOFU%FFQ-FBSOJOH+1EMHRO • ʮࠓ·ͰͷهԱ͔ΒະདྷΛ༧ଌ͢ΔྗɽͦΕ͕ೳͰ͋Δɽʯ • δΣϑɾϗʔΩϯεʰߟ͑Δɾߟ͑Δίϯϐϡʔλʱ • ֶशͨ͠෦Λ༻͍ͯະདྷΛγϛϡϨʔγϣϯ͠ͳ͕Βߦಈ͍ͯ͠Δ ͱߟ͑ΒΕΔ 4
ྑ͍දͱݱʁ ੜͷ؍ଌใͷແؔ࿈ͳ෦Λແࢹͯ͠ɼڧԽֶशʹར༻͢ΔͨΊʹඞཁෆՄܽͳ ใΛΤϯίʔυ͢Δ͜ͱ͕ඞཁ <#ÖINFSFUBM >ʹΑΔྑ͍ঢ়ଶදݱͷఆٛ • Ϛϧίϑੑ͕͋Δ • ࡏݱͷঢ়ଶͷΈΛݟΔ͚ͩͰɼ͋ΔํࡦΛ༻͍ͯߦಈΛબ͢Δ͜ͱ͕Ͱ͖Δ͙Β͍ेͳ ใΛཁ͍ͯ͠Δ • ํࡦͷվળͷͨΊʹར༻Ͱ͖Δ • ಉ͡Α͏ͳಛΛ࣋ͭͱͨ͜ݟͷͳ͍ঢ়ଶʹɼֶशͨ͠ՁؔΛ൚ԽͰ͖Δ • ࣍͋ͰݩΔ 5
SRLͷҰൠԽ ˜ st ∈ 𝒮 43-Ͱਅͷঢ়ଶɹɹɹΛΘͣʹɼ͜ΕΛۙࣅ͢ΔΑ͏ͳঢ়ଶɹɹɹΛֶश͢Δ s̃t ∈ 𝒮 o1:t st = ϕ (o1:t) st • աڈͷ؍ଌɹɹ͔Βࡏݱͷঢ়ଶɹͷϚοϐϯάɹɹɹɹɹɹͷֶश ߦಈ at ∈ 𝒜 ਅͷঢ়ଶ ෆ໌ at ˜ s̃t ∈ 𝒮 s̃t ؍ଌ ot ot ∈ 𝒪 s̃t+1 ใु ot+1 6
SRLͷΞϓϩʔν 43-ͷΞϓϩʔνʹ͍͔ͭ͘ύλʔϯ͕͋Δ • ࣗ߸ූݾԽ ثBVUPFODPEFS ͷར༻ • ॱϞσϧ GPSXBSENPEFM ͷར༻ • ٯϞσϧ JOWFSTFNPEFM ͷར༻ • ࣄલࣝ QSJPS ͷಋೖ 7
SRLͷΞϓϩʔν ࣗ߸ූݾԽ ثBVUPFODPEFS ͷར༻ • ࠶ߏࠩޡͷ࠷খԽΛ͢Δ͜ͱͰɼΤϯίʔμɹͱσίʔμɹɹΛֶश ϕ ϕ −1 st • ͦͷࡍɼঢ়ଶɹ͕͋Δੑ࣭Λ࣋ͭΑ͏ʹ੍Λ͔͚Δ • ྫ ࣍ݩͷ੍ɼϊΠζͷআ ڈEFOPJTJOH ɼεύʔεੑͷ੍ Τϯίʔμ st = ϕ (ot; θϕ) σίʔμ ot̂ = ϕ −1 (st; θϕ−1) ࠶ߏࠩޡ 8
SRLͷΞϓϩʔν ॱϞσϧ GPSXBSENPEFM ͷར༻ st+1 at st f • ॱϞσϧɹঢ়ଶɹͱߦಈɹΛ༻͍ͯ࣍ͷঢ়ଶɹɹΛ༧ଌ • ॱϞσϧʹઢܗมͲͳͷ੍Λ͔͚Δ͜ͱ͕Ͱ͖Δ ϕ • Τϯίʔμɹ࣍ͷঢ়ଶͷ༧ଌࠩޡΛٯͤ͞Δ͜ͱͰֶश͞ΕΔ ॱϞσϧ ̂ = f (st, at; θf wd) st+1 Τϯίʔμ st = ϕ (ot; θϕ) ࣍ͷঢ়ଶͷ༧ଌࠩޡ 9
SRLͷΞϓϩʔν ٯϞσϧ JOWFSTFNPEFM ͷར༻ st+1 at st • ঢ়ଶɹͱ࣍ͷঢ়ଶɹɹ͔Β࣮ࡍʹऔΒΕͨߦಈɹΛਪఆ͢Δ at ϕ • Τϯίʔμɹ࣮ࡍʹͱΒΕͨߦಈɹͷ༧ଌࠩޡΛٯͤ͞Δ͜ͱͰֶश͞ΕΔ ࣮ࡍʹऔΒΕͨ ߦಈͷ༧ଌࠩޡ ٯϞσϧ at̂ = g (st, st+1; θinv) Τϯίʔμ st = ϕ (ot; θϕ) 10
SRLͷΞϓϩʔν ࣄલࣝ QSJPS ͷಋೖ • ಛఆͷ੍μΠφϛΫεʹؔ͢ΔࣄલࣝΛར༻͢Δ • ྫ ࣌ؒతͳ࿈ଓੑ s1:n c • ࣄલࣝ͋Δ݅ɹͷͱͰɼঢ়ଶͷू߹ɹɹʹద༻͞ΕΔMPTTΛ௨ͯ͡ఆٛ͞ΕΔ • Loss = ℒprior (s1:n; θϕ | c) Τϯίʔμ st = ϕ (ot; θϕ) ঢ়ଶͷۭؒࣗମʹ ੍Λ͓͘ 11
Why SRL? ͳͥ43-Λߟ͑Δ͖ͳͷ͔ • ੜͷ؍ଌ͔ΒFOEUPFOEʹڧԽֶश͢Δͷίετ͕ߴ͍ • 43-Ͱྑ͍QSJPSΛೖΕͯ͋͛Δ͜ͱ͕Ͱ͖Δ͔ • ϚϧνϞʔμϧͳ؍ଌʹ֦ு͠ಘΔ • ؔ࿈ͨ͠λεΫΛࣄલʹղ͘͜ͱͰసҠֶशʹར༻Ͱ͖Δ • ਐԽઓུ &4 ͳͲͷɼ࣍ࡧ୳͕ݩεϐʔυʹ݁͢ΔΑ͏ͳΞϧΰϦζϜΛ࠾༻͢Δ͜ͱ ͕ՄೳʹͳΔ 12
طଘͷڀݚͷհͱྨ 13
ڀݚͷྨ ྨͷํ๏ • ֶशͷతؔ • ؍ଌۭؒɾߦಈۭؒͷઃܭ • ঢ়ଶදݱͷධՁࢦඪ • ධՁʹ༻͍ΔλεΫ 14
ֶशͷతؔ • ؍ଌͷ࠶ߏ • ॱϞσϧ GPSXBSENPEFM ͷֶश • ٯϞσϧ JOWFSTFNPEFM ͷֶश • ಛͷఢରతֶशͷ༻׆ • ใुͷ༻׆ • ͦͷଞͷతؔ • ϋΠϒϦουͳతؔ 15
ֶशͷతؔ ؍ଌͷ࠶ߏ • ࣍ݩѹॖͱͯ͠Α͘ΘΕΔํ๏ • ྫ 1$"<$VSSBO >ɼ%"&ɼ7"&<WBO)PPG >ɽ • ࣗ߸ූݾԽ ثBVUPFODPEFS Λ͏ख๏͕ଟ͍ • ը૾ͷ؍ଌΛͦͷ··͏<.BUUOFS > • ΦϒδΣΫτͷҐஔΛද͢ݱΔΑ͏ʹ੍͢Δྫ 4QBUJBM4PGUNBY<'JOO > • ؍ଌʹཱͭಛ͕ଘࡏͯ͠ͳ͍ͱ୯ʹ؍ଌΛ࠶ߏ͢Δ͚ͩͰྑ͍දʹݱͳΒͳ͍ • • ྫ ήʔϜʹ͓͚Δখ͍͞ΞΠςϜ ҧ͏࣌ؒεςοϓ͔Β࠶ߏͨ͠Γɼ࣌ؒൃలʹ੍ؔͯ͠Λ͔͚Δ͜ͱͰରԠ 16
ֶशͷతؔ ॱϞσϧ GPSXBSENPEFM ͷֶश • ঢ়ଶ͕࣍ͷঢ়ଶΛ༧ଌ͢ΔͷʹඞཁͳใΛΤϯίʔυ͢ΔΑ͏ʹ͢Δ • ؍ଌͷ࠶ߏͱΑ͘Έ߹ΘͤΒΕΔ • ঢ়ଶۭؒʹ͓͚ΔભҠΛઢͱܗԾఆ͢Δ͜ͱ͕ଟ͍ ̂ = Wst + Uat + V st+1 17
E2C [Watter+ 2015]
&NCFEUP$POUSPM"-PDBMMZ-JOFBS-BUFOU%ZOBNJDT.PEFMGPS$POUSPMGSPN
3BX*NBHFT
• 7"&Λ༻͍ͨॱϞσϧɽঢ়ଶ જࡏදݱst ɹͷભҠΛઢ͋ͰܗΔͱԾఆ
̂ ∼ 𝒩 (μ = Wst + Uat + V, σ)
st+1
ઢܗ
st+1
• ࣍ͷ࣌ؒεςοϓͷঢ়ଶͷ༧ଌɹɹͱͦͷঢ়ଶɹɹͷ,-Λ
̂
st+1
͚ۙͮΔ͜ͱͰॱϞσϧΛֶश
• ΧϧϚϯϑΟϧλͱͯ͠ఆࣜԽͨ͠ͷ͋Δ %7#'
<,BSM >
18
World Model [Ha+ 2018] 8PSME.PEFMT • 7"&ͱ.%/3//Λར༻ͨ͠ॱϞσϧ • 7JTJPONPEFM 7 ߴ࣍ݩͷ؍ଌσʔλΛ7"&Λ༻͍ͯ ࣍ݩͷίʔυ ঢ়ଶ ʹѹॖ • .FNPSZ3// . աڈͷίʔυ͔Β࣍ͷεςοϓͷ ίʔυ ঢ়ଶ Λ༧ଌ <%-ྠಡձ>8PSME.PEFMT IUUQTXXXTMJEFTIBSFOFU%FFQ-FBSOJOH+1EMXPSMENPEFMT 19
ֶशͷతؔ ٯϞσϧ JOWFSTFNPEFM ͷֶश • ͱͬͨߦಈΛਪఆͰ͖ΔΑ͏ʹঢ়ଶͷද੍ʹݱΛ՝͢ • ྫ -FBSOJOHUP1PLFCZ1PLJOH<"HSBXBM > • ͍ͭͬͭͨҐஔ ɹ pt ɼ֯ ɹ θt ɼ ڑɹ lt Λਪఆ 20
ICM [Pathak+ 2017] $VSJPTJUZESJWFO&YQMPSBUJPOCZ4FMGTVQFSWJTFE1SFEJDUJPO ℒf wd • ॱϞσϧͷ༧ଌࠩޡɹɹΛڧԽֶशͷతใुͱͯ͠ར༻ • ΤʔδΣϯτͷ֎෦͔Βͷใु͕εύʔεͳͱ͖ʹ୳ࡧΛଅਐ͢Δ 1 ℒf wd ϕ̂ (ot+1), f ̂ (ϕ̂ (ot), at) = ( ) 2 f ̂ (ϕ̂ (ot), at) − ϕ̂ (ot+1) 2 2 • ٯϞσϧʹΑΔ-PTTར༻ min [−λ𝔼π(st; θP) [Σtrt] + (1 − β)ℒinv + βℒf wd] θ ,θ ,θ P I F ֎తใु ٯϞσϧ ॱϞσϧ <%-ྠಡձ>-BSHF4DBMF4UVEZPG$VSJPTJUZ%SJWFO-FBSOJOH ઌिͷൃද IUUQTXXXTMJEFTIBSFOFU%FFQ-FBSOJOH+1EMMBSHFTDBMFTUVEZPGDVSJPTJUZESJWFOMFBSOJOH 21
ֶशͷతؔ ಛͷఢରతֶश • ྫ $BVTBM*OGP("/<,VSVUBDI > • ("/ͷతؔʹঢ়ଶͱ(FOFSBUPSͷग़ྗ ؍ଌͷϖΞ ͷ૬ޓใྔʹؔ͢Δਖ਼ଇԽ߲ΛՃ min max G,Q,ℳ D V(G, D) − λIVLB(G, Q) ૬ޓใྔ 22
ֶशͷతؔ ใुͷ༻׆ • 4-3ʹ͓͍ͯใुΛར༻͢Δ͜ͱඞͣ͠ඞཁͰͳ͍͕ɼঢ়ଶΛ۠ผ͢ΔͨΊͷ Ճతͳใͱͯ͠ར༻͠͏Δ • ྫ 71/<0I > • ࣍ͷঢ়ଶͱͦͷঢ়ଶՁ༧ଌ ؍ଌ ঢ়ଶ ࣍ͷঢ়ଶՁ ߦಈ ˞PQUJPOͷP ࣍ͷঢ়ଶ 23
ֶशͷతؔ ͦͷଞͷతؔ • ࣮ੈքʹؔ͢Δࣄલࣝ QSJPS Λঢ়ଶۭؒʹө͢ΔͨΊʹɼతؔΛ͢Δ • ͍Ζ͍Ζͳͷ͕ఏҊ͞Ε͍ͯΔ • 4MPXOFTTQSJPS<-FTPSU +POTDILPXTLJ > • ॏཁͳͷΏͬ͘Γͱ࿈ଓతʹಈ͖ɼͳܹٸมԽ͕͜ىΔՄೳੑ͍ ℒSlowness(D, ϕ) = 𝔼 [ Δst ] 2 • 7BSJBCJMJUZ<+POTDILPXTLJ > • ؔͷ͋Δͷಈ͘ͷͰɼঢ়ଶදֶݱशಈ͍͍ͯΔͷʹ͖͢ ℒVariabilty(D, ϕ) = 𝔼 [e − st1 − st2 ] 24
ֶशͷతؔ ͦͷଞͷతؔ • 3PCPUJD1SJPST<+POTDILPXTLJ >Ͱಋೖ͞Ε͍ͯΔͷ • 1SPQPSUJPOBMJUZ • ҧ͏ঢ়ଶͰಉ͡ߦಈΛͨ͠߹ʹɼঢ়ଶʹ͢΅ٴӨڹಉఔͰ͋Δ ℒProp(D, ϕ) = 𝔼 ( [ Δst2 − Δst1 ) | at1 = at2] 2 • 3FQFBUBCJMJUZ • ࣅͨঢ়ଶͰಉ͡ߦಈΛͨ͠߹ʹɼঢ়ଶʹ͢΅ٴӨڹಉఔɾಉ͡ํͰ͋Δ ℒRep(D, ϕ) = 𝔼 e [ − st2 − st1 2 Δst2 − Δst1 2 ] | at1 = at2 25
ֶशͷతؔ ϋΠϒϦουͳతؔ • ࣮ࡍࠓ·Ͱʹͨ͛ڍతؔͷ͏ͪɼෳΛΈ߹Θͤͯ43-͕ߦΘΕΔ͜ͱ͕ଟ͍ ߦಈ/࣍ͷঢ়ଶ ॱϞσϧ ※࣍ͷঢ়ଶͷ༧ଌ ͷ੍ E2C [Watter+ 2015] World Model [Ha+ 2018] ICM [Pathak+ 2017] Causal InfoGAN [Kurutach+ 2018] ࣍ͷ؍ଌͷ ༧ଌ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ [Oh+ 2017] [Jonschkowski+ 2015] ؍ଌͷ࠶ߏ ✔ VPN Robotic Priors ٯϞσϧ ✔ ใुͷ༻׆ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ 26
؍ଌɾঢ়ଶɾߦಈۭؒͷઃܭ • ؍ଌɾঢ়ଶɾߦಈۭؒͷઃܭͷෳࡶੑʹӨڹΛ͢΅ٴ • Ͳͷ͘Β͍ͷ࣍ݩͷେ͖͔͞ɼߦಈ͕ࢄ͔ɾ࿈ଓ͔ • ௨ৗɼਅͷঢ়ଶΑΓେ͖ͳঢ়ଶۭؒͷ࣍ݩΛઃ͢ܭΔ͜ͱ͕ଟ͍ • Ͳͷ͘Β͍ͷ࣍ݩͷେ͖͔͞ɼߦಈ͕ࢄ͔ɾ࿈ଓ͔ • ঢ়ଶΛͲͷ͙Β͍ͷ࣍͢ʹݩΕ͍͍͔Α͘Θ͔Βͳ͍λεΫଟ͍ྫ "UBSJ Robotic Priors [Jon-schkowski+ 2015] E2C [Watter+ 2015] ICM [Pathak+ 2017] ڥ ؍ଌͷछྨ ؍ଌۭؒͷ࣍ݩ ঢ়ଶͷ࣍ݩ ߦಈ slot car racing ը૾ 16×16×3 2 ࢄ(25) cart-pole ը૾ 80×80×3 8 ࢄ Mario Bros. ը૾ 42×42×3 2 ࢄ(14) 27
ঢ়ଶදݱͷධՁࢦඪ Ͳ͏ͬͯঢ়ଶදݱͷྑ͞ΛධՁ͢Δ͔ʁ • ΤʔδΣϯτʹ࣮ࡍʹڧԽֶशλεΫΛղ͔ͤͯɼλεΫؒͰసҠ͙Β͍൚Խ͞Εͨදݱ ʹͳ͍ͬͯΔ͔ΛௐΔ • ͬͱҰൠతͳํ๏͕ͩɼ࣮ݧίετ͕ߴ͍ • ͲͷڧԽֶशΞϧΰϦζϜΛͬͯධՁ͢Ε͍͍͔Θ͔Βͳ͍ • ͳͷͰɼֶशͨ͠ঢ়ଶද͔͏Ͳ͔͍ྑ͕ݱͷதؒతͳධՁख๏͕ཉ͍͠ • ࠷ۙ๏Λ͏ • ࣭తධՁ • ྔతධՁ ,//.4&<-FTPSU > KNN − MSE(s) = 1 k ∑ s̃ − s̃′ 2 s′∈KNN(s,k) 28
ঢ়ଶදݱͷධՁࢦඪ Ͳ͏ͬͯঢ়ଶදݱͷྑ͞ΛධՁ͢Δ͔ʁ • ͭΕͷͳ͍ද ݱEJTFOUBOHMFE ͔Ͳ͏͔ΛΈΔ • EJTFOUBOHMFENFUSJDTDPSF<)JHHJOT > • σʔλͷഎޙͷੜཁҼ͕͔͍ͬͯΔલఏ • ༰ྔ͕খ͘͞7$࣍ݩͷখ͍͞ผثͷBDDVSBDZΛ༻͍Δํ๏ • ਅͷঢ়ଶͷճؼϞσϧΛ࡞Δ<+POTDILPXTLJ > • ςετηοτͷਫ਼ΛධՁ͢Δ 29
ঢ়ଶදݱͷධՁࢦඪ Ͳ͏ͬͯঢ়ଶදݱͷྑ͞ΛධՁ͢Δ͔ʁ 30
ධՁʹ༻͍ΔλεΫ 43-Ͱఆ൪ͷλεΫ • ৼࢠɾཱৼࢠ • ϥϯμϜͳҐஔ͔Βελʔτ͢ΔৼࢠΛཱͯΔ • $BSU1PMF • ंͷཱ͍ͭͨৼࢠΛཱͯΔ • ਨํ͔ΒͣΕΔ͔த৺͔ΒϢχοτͿΜͣΕͯ͠·͏ͱΤϐιʔυ͕ऴྃ͢Δ 31
ධՁʹ༻͍ΔλεΫ 43-Ͱఆ൪ͷλεΫ • ϏσΦήʔϜ • ྫ "UBSJɼ%PPNɼ4VQFS.BSJP#SPT • ཧγϛϡϨʔλ • ྫ 0QFO"*(ZNɼ%FFQ.JOE-BCT • ࣮ϩϘοτ • ྫ ϚχϐϡϨʔγϣϯ<'JOO >ɼϘλϯԡ͠<-FTPSU >ɼ࣋<'JOO > 32
S-RL Toolbox 43-ΞϧΰϦζϜͷධՁʹؔ͢Δ͍Ζ͍ΖΛղܾ͢Δπʔϧ<3BGGJO > • IUUQTHJUIVCDPNBSBGGJOSPCPUJDTSMTSM • ଟ༷ͳػೳ • छྨͷڧԽֶशΞϧΰϦζϜ • 0QFO"*(ZNࣜܗͷΠϯλʔϑΣΠεΛ࣋ͭධՁڥ • ϩΨʔɾՄࢹԽπʔϧ • ϋΠύʔύϥϝʔλαʔνπʔϧ • ࣮ػͷCBYUFSͰूΊͨσʔληοτ • 43-ͷ࣮ू43-;PPͱͯ͠·ؚΕ͍ͯΔ • IUUQTHJUIVCDPNBSBGGJOTSM[PPUSFF EFBGBBCGBED • 1Z5PSDIͰ͏Ε͍͠ 33
͓ΘΓʹ 34
ײ • ঢ়ଶදͲͯؔ͠ʹݱΕ͚ͩෆ࣮֬ੑ͕͋Δͷ͔ΛධՁ͢Δڀݚ͋ΔͷͩΖ͏͔ʁ • ྫ͑ɼ࠷ॳͷϑϨʔϜ͚ͩͱ͖ͱͨݟɼϑϨʔϜ࿈ଓͰͰ͖ͱͨݟͦͷঢ়ଶදݱͷෆ ࣮֬ੑҟͳΔͣ • ͦͷෆ࣮֬ੑΛөͨ͠QPMJDZ͕࡞ΕΕޮతͳ୳ࡧʹͭͳ͕Δʁ • ͨ͘͞ΜͷλεΫΛղ͔ͤͯ43-ͯ͠ɼྑ͍43-ͷύϥϝʔλΛֶशͨ͠ͷͪɼGFXTIPU Ͱ৽͍͠λεΫʹద߹ͤ͞Δ.".-తͳΞϓϩʔν͕༗ޮ͔ • ͦͦɼ43-Λ͍ͨͪ࣋͠ؾɼͨ͘͞ΜͷλεΫͰڞ༗Ͱ͖ΔදݱΛֶश͍͔ͨ͠Βͩͬ ͨͷͰʁ • • ·͋ɼ࣮ݧίετ͕ߴ͍ͷͰɼจͰͨ͘͞ΜͷυϝΠϯΛͬͨڧԽֶशΛͨ͘͠ͳ͍ͷΘ ͔Δ͚Ͳʜ .".-पΓͰͨ͘͞Μจ͕ग़͖͍ͯͯΔͷͰɼ࣍ճͷେϝλϥʔχϯάʹ͠Α͏͔ͳ 35
Appendix 36
References
<"HSBXBM >1VMLJU"HSBXBM "TIWJO/BJS 1JFUFS"CCFFM +JUFOESB.BMJL 4FSHFZ-FWJOF -FBSOJOHUP
1PLFCZ1PLJOH&YQFSJFOUJBM-FBSOJOHPG*OUVJUJWF1IZTJDTIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<#ÖINFS >#ÖINFS 8 4QSJOHFOCFSH +5 #PFEFDLFS + 3JFENJMMFS . BOE0CFSNBZFS ,
"VUPOPNPVTMFBSOJOHPGTUBUFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOTGPSDPOUSPM"OFNFSHJOHGJFMEBJNTUPBVUPOPNPVTMZMFBSOTUBUF
SFQSFTFOUBUJPOTGPSSFJOGPSDFNFOUMFBSOJOHBHFOUTGSPNUIFJSSFBMXPSMETFOTPSPCTFSWBUJPOT,*,ÛOTUMJDIF
*OUFMMJHFO[ QBHFTrIUUQXXXOJUVCFSMJOEFGJMFBENJOGHBSUJDMFTCPFINFSCQEG
<$VSSBO >8JMMJBN$VSSBO 5JN#SZT .BUUIFX5BZMPS 8JMMJBN4NBSU 6TJOH1$"UP&GGJDJFOUMZ
3FQSFTFOU4UBUF4QBDFTIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<'JOO >$IFMTFB'JOO 9JO:V5BO :BO%VBO 5SFWPS%BSSFMM 4FSHFZ-FWJOF 1JFUFS"CCFFM %FFQ
4QBUJBM"VUPFODPEFSTGPS7JTVPNPUPS-FBSOJOHIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<)B >%BWJE)B +ÛSHFO4DINJEIVCFS 8PSME.PEFMTIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<)JHHJOT >*SJOB)JHHJOT -PJD.BUUIFZ "SLB1BM $ISJTUPQIFS#VSHFTT 9BWJFS(MPSPU .BUUIFX
#PUWJOJDL 4IBLJS.PIBNFE "MFYBOEFS-FSDIOFS CFUB7"&-FBSOJOH#BTJD7JTVBM$PODFQUTXJUIB
$POTUSBJOFE7BSJBUJPOBM'SBNFXPSLIUUQTPQFOSFWJFXOFUGPSVN JE4ZG[6HM
37
References
<+POTDILPXTLJ >+POTDILPXTLJ 3BOE#SPDL 0 -FBSOJOHTUBUFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOTXJUISPCPUJD
QSJPST"VUPO3PCPUT rIUUQXXXSPCPUJDTUVCFSMJOEFGJMFBENJOGH1VCMJLBUJPOFO@QEG
+POTDILPXTLJ"630QEG
<+POTDILPXTLJ >3JDP+POTDILPXTLJ 3PMBOE)BGOFS +POBUIBO4DIPM[ .BSUJO3JFENJMMFS 17&T
1PTJUJPO7FMPDJUZ&ODPEFSTGPS6OTVQFSWJTFE-FBSOJOHPG4USVDUVSFE4UBUF3FQSFTFOUBUJPOTIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<,BSM >.BYJNJMJBO,BSM .BYJNJMJBO4PFMDI +VTUJO#BZFS 1BUSJDLWBOEFS4NBHU%FFQ7BSJBUJPOBM#BZFT
'JMUFST6OTVQFSWJTFE-FBSOJOHPG4UBUF4QBDF.PEFMTGSPN3BX%BUBIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<,VSVUBDI >5IBOBSE,VSVUBDI "WJW5BNBS (F:BOH 4UVBSU3VTTFMM 1JFUFS"CCFFM -FBSOJOH
1MBOOBCMF3FQSFTFOUBUJPOTXJUI$BVTBM*OGP("/IUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<-BLF ^#VJMEJOH.BDIJOFT5IBU-FBSOBOE5IJOL-JLF1FPQMF #SFOEFO.-BLF 5PNFS%
6MMNBO +PTIVB#5FOFOCBVN 4BNVFM+(FSTINBOIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<0I >+VOIZVL0I 4BUJOEFS4JOHI )POHMBL-FF 7BMVF1SFEJDUJPO/FUXPSLIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<1BUIBL >%FFQBL1BUIBL 1VMLJU"HSBXBM "MFYFJ"&GSPT 5SFWPS%BSSFMM $VSJPTJUZESJWFO
&YQMPSBUJPOCZ4FMGTVQFSWJTFE1SFEJDUJPOIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
38
References
<3BGGJO >"OUPOJO3BGGJO "TIMFZ)JMM 3FOÉ5SBPSÉ 5JNPUIÉF-FTPSU /BUBMJB%ÍB[3PESÍHVF[ %BWJE'JMMJBU
43-5PPMCPY&OWJSPONFOUT %BUBTFUTBOE&WBMVBUJPO.FUSJDTGPS4UBUF3FQSFTFOUBUJPO-FBSOJOHIUUQT
BSYJWPSHBCT
<-FTPSU >5JNPUIÉF-FTPSU .BUIJFV4FVSJO 9JOSVJ-J /BUBMJB%ÍB[3PESÍHVF[ %BWJE'JMMJBU
6OTVQFSWJTFETUBUFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOMFBSOJOHXJUISPCPUJDQSJPSTBSPCVTUOFTTCFODINBSLIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
<.BUUOFS >.BUUOFS + -BOHF 4 BOE3JFENJMMFS ." -FBSOUPTXJOHVQBOECBMBODFBSFBMQPMF
CBTFEPOSBXWJTVBMJOQVUEBUB*O/FVSBM*OGPSNBUJPO1SPDFTTJOHUI*OUFSOBUJPOBM$POGFSFODF *$0/*1
%PIB 2BUBS /PWFNCFS 1SPDFFEJOHT 1BSU7 QBHFTrIUUQTJFFFYQMPSFJFFFPSHEPDVNFOU
<WBO)PPG >WBO)PPG ) $IFO / ,BSM . WBOEFS4NBHU 1 BOE1FUFST + 4UBCMFSFJOGPSDFNFOU
MFBSOJOHXJUIBVUPFODPEFSTGPSUBDUJMFBOEWJTVBMEBUB*O*&&&34+*OUFSOBUJPOBM$POGFSFODFPO*OUFMMJHFOU
3PCPUTBOE4ZTUFNT *304 QBHFTrIUUQTJFFFYQMPSFJFFFPSHEPDVNFOU
<8BUUFS >.BOVFM8BUUFS +PTU5PCJBT4QSJOHFOCFSH +PTDILB#PFEFDLFS .BSUJO3JFENJMMFS &NCFE
UP$POUSPM"-PDBMMZ-JOFBS-BUFOU%ZOBNJDT.PEFMGPS$POUSPMGSPN3BX*NBHFTIUUQTBSYJWPSHBCT
39